Get Found · Chapter 10 of 12
Measuring what matters
You cannot tell whether your SEO work is paying off unless you measure it, and most practices either measure nothing or drown in charts. This chapter sets up the three free tools you need, names the handful of numbers worth watching, and shows you how to read a bad month without making it worse.
Set up the three free tools
Three free tools cover almost everything a practice owner needs. Keep the logins in your own name. If a developer or marketer set them up for you, make sure your own account is listed as an owner.
Google Search Console
Search Console shows how Google sees your site: which searches you appear for, how often people click, which pages are indexed and whether anything is broken.
- Go to Google Search Console and sign in with the Google account you use for the practice.
- Add your site as a “Domain” property. This covers the
wwwand non-wwwversions and bothhttpandhttpsin one go. - Verify ownership by adding the TXT record Google gives you to your domain’s DNS settings.
- Submit your XML sitemap under Sitemaps (Chapter 6 covers what that is).
Google says Search Console keeps 16 months of performance history, so export a copy of the Performance report every few months if you want a longer record.
Bing Webmaster Tools
Bing matters more than its market share suggests, because Microsoft Copilot runs on Bing’s index and other AI tools draw on it too.
- Sign in to Bing Webmaster Tools.
- Choose the option to import your site from Google Search Console.
Google Analytics 4
Search Console tells you what happened before someone reached your site. GA4 tells you what they did after they arrived: which pages they read and whether they called, filled in a form or booked.
- Create a GA4 property and a web data stream for your site.
- Add the tag to your site. Most website platforms have a field for the measurement ID; a custom site needs your developer to add it.
- Link GA4 to Search Console under Admin, then Product links.
- Set up key events (GA4’s name for conversions) for the actions that matter to you. The next section covers which ones.
Analytics that only counts visitors tells you nothing about whether the site brings in work.
Watch for
If you use analytics on a site for a health or legal practice, check your privacy obligations. Do not send names, health details or case details into GA4 in form fields or page addresses, and make sure your privacy policy says you use analytics.
The few numbers worth watching
You need a short list, checked monthly, in this order of importance.
| Number | Where to find it | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Booked consults or new patients from the website | Your intake records | Whether the site brings in work. This is the number that pays the rent. |
| Calls from the website and your Business Profile | Call tracking, GA4 key events, Business Profile performance | How many people picked up the phone after finding you |
| Form submissions and online bookings | GA4 key events | How many people contacted you without calling |
| Clicks from Google | Search Console, Performance report | How many people chose your result |
| Impressions | Search Console, Performance report | How often you appeared in results at all |
| Top queries | Search Console, Performance report, Queries tab | What people typed before finding you |
Read the table from the bottom up and you see the pipeline: people search, Google shows you, some click, and some of those contact you. Read it from the top down to judge whether the work is paying off.
A few points on reading Search Console:
- Impressions usually rise before clicks. Rising impressions with flat clicks often means you are not yet near the top, or your titles need work (Chapter 4).
- Average position mixes every search you appeared for, including obscure ones. Check position for your important queries one at a time instead.
- Appearances in Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted in the Search Console web totals but not shown as a separate line, so you cannot see exactly which clicks came from an AI answer.
GA4 shows visits from AI assistants such as chatgpt.com and perplexity.ai as referral traffic under Traffic acquisition. The numbers will be small. Pair them with the monthly question check from Chapter 8.
Tracking calls and forms
For many practices the phone is where the work comes in. Measure forms alone and you may miss most of it. Start simple:
- Make every phone number on your site a tap-to-call link.
- Set up a GA4 key event for clicks on those links. It counts people who tapped to call, though it cannot tell you whether they got through.
- Set up a GA4 key event for each form’s thank-you page or submission.
- Check the Performance section of your Google Business Profile monthly. It shows calls, website clicks and direction requests from your profile.
- Ask every new client or patient how they found you, and record the answer in your intake notes. This costs nothing and catches what software misses: “my cousin sent me your website” or “ChatGPT suggested you”.
For firmer numbers, a call tracking service can show website visitors a different number and log each call. Use the service’s script to swap the number, so your real number stays in the page code. On your Business Profile, Google’s guidance is to put the tracking number in the primary phone field and your main number in the additional phone field, which keeps the consistency you built in Chapters 7 and 8. If the service records calls, check your privacy and regulator obligations first, and tell callers.
How long this takes
SEO is slow. Expect months, not weeks.
- A new page can be indexed within days, but it usually takes weeks for its ranking to settle.
- Improvements to an existing site often show up in Search Console impressions within one to three months.
- Steady growth in calls and bookings usually takes three to twelve months, depending on how competitive your area and practice are.
Judge your tactics month to month, but judge your results by the quarter. Compare each month with the same month last year once you have a year of data, because practices are seasonal. Tax season fills accounting offices; your own practice has its own rhythm, and a year of data will show it.
When the numbers drop
Sooner or later you will see a line going down. Work through the boring causes first, in this order:
- Confirm the drop is real. Check Search Console clicks, not a third-party tool’s estimate, and note the date it started.
- Check whether tracking broke. A site update can remove the GA4 tag or break a form’s thank-you page, and leads appear to vanish when they are still coming in.
- Check whether the site broke. Look at the Pages report in Search Console for a jump in errors, run a URL Inspection on your home page, and confirm the site loads on your phone. A stray “noindex” setting or an expired security certificate can do it.
- Check the season. Compare with the same period last year.
- Check the search results themselves. If an AI Overview now answers a question you used to win clicks for, your impressions can stay flat while clicks fall. The cause is Google’s layout. Your page did nothing wrong.
- Check Manual actions and Security issues in Search Console. If Google has flagged your site, it will say so there.
- Check whether Google announced an update. Google posts confirmed core and spam updates on its Search Status Dashboard. If your drop lines up with one, Google re-scored your pages against everyone else’s. See which pages lost ground and who gained, then improve your content honestly (Chapter 5). Recovery often comes at a later update, months out.
The worst reaction is to change ten things at once. Make one change, note the date in your log, and give it time. Otherwise you will never know what fixed it.
Try this with AI
Export the Queries table from your Search Console Performance report (last three months) as a spreadsheet and paste it in. Remove anything that could identify a client or patient first. Check every conclusion against your own data before acting on it.
I run a [type of practice] in [city], Ontario. Below is a Search Console export of the searches my site appeared for over the last three months, with clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position. Tell me: (1) which searches show the most potential, where I have many impressions but few clicks, (2) which searches suggest I should create or improve a page, and (3) any searches that have nothing to do with my practice. Keep it short and practical.
[paste data here]
My website's clicks from Google dropped by about [percentage] starting around [date]. My practice is a [type of practice] in [city], Ontario. Walk me through, in plain language, the checks I should do in Google Search Console and GA4 to find the cause, starting with the most common and least alarming explanations.
Your checklist
- Verify your site in Google Search Console as a Domain property and submit your sitemap.
- Import your site into Bing Webmaster Tools from Search Console.
- Confirm GA4 is installed, linked to Search Console, and that you are listed as an admin in your own name.
- Set up GA4 key events for phone link clicks, form submissions and online bookings.
- Add “How did you hear about us?” to your intake process and record every answer.
- Create a simple monthly log: consults or new patients from the website, calls, forms, Search Console clicks and impressions, and any changes you made.
- Note this month’s numbers as your baseline, and set a calendar reminder to compare them in three months.